Selection of Material and Manufacturing Technology for Batik Canting Stamps Based on Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Methods
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5614/j.eng.technol.sci.2023.55.4.7Keywords:
batik, stamp canting, multi-criteria decision-making, SAW, TOPSIS, PROMETHEEAbstract
This study aimed to develop alternative materials and technologies for making canting stamps used in producing batik canting (stamped batik) to transfer hot wax from the pan to the fabric. Previous researchers have studied materials such as wood, aluminum, multiplex, acrylic, and acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS). Manufacturing technologies have also been analyzed, including manual manufacturing, computer numerical control (CNC) milling, laser cutting, and additive manufacturing. However, none of these materials and technologies were considered suitable alternatives for copper canting stamps. This paper proposes Conductive ABS-Electroformed By Copper (CABS-EBC) through additive manufacturing and electroforming processes as alternative material for canting stamps. A multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) approach was used to assess alternative materials and technologies. The alternatives and criteria were calculated using the Simple Additive Weighting (SAW), Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), and Preference Ranking Organization Method of Enrichment Evaluation (PROMETHEE) techniques. Besides this, assessment was also carried out based on expert opinions. The results showed that copper was the most suitable material, with Closeness = 1.000, Yi = 0.995, and Phi = +1.00. Meanwhile, CABS-EBC ranked second, with Closeness = 0.627, Yi = 0.864, and Phi = +0.50. The selected technology was additive manufacturing combined with electroforming, with Closeness = 0.700, Yi = 0.895, and Phi = +0.39. By using MCDM on the material-technology development candidates it was found that CABS-EBC processed with additive manufacturing is capable of substituting copper as a canting stamp material. It is expected that the production capacity of the traditional manufacturing process can be enhanced by adopting these new materials and technologies.
Downloads
References
BSN, SNI 0239:2019 Batik ? Definition and Term, Jakarta, 2019.
Sekar, A.Y., An Innovation of Textile Surface Design through the Development of Block Printing Techniques using Modular Stamp as a Step to Reduce Gas Emissions in Fashion Manufacturing, Proceeding International Conference on Information Technology, Multimedia, Architecture, Design & E ? Business, 1, pp. 62-70, 2020.
Suharto, S., Suryanto, S., Priyo, V.T.S., Sarana, S., Hermawan, I. & Suwondo, A., Alternative Material for Making Canting Batik Cap (CBC), Prosiding SNST, 1(1), pp. 25-31, 2014.
Sudarto, S., Strategy for Making Canting Caps from Copper to Improve Batik Quality Results, Institut Seni Indonesia, Surakarta, October 2017.
Antara, The Increase in the Price of Copper as a Raw Material has an Impact on Canting Makers in Pekalongan, Beritasatu.com, https://www.beritasatu.com/fashion/12112-pabrik-canting-pekalongan-terancam-bangkrut.html. (25-Feb-2019). (Text in Indonesian)
The Ministry of Industry, Absorbing 200 Thousand Workers, Batik Industry Exports Reach USD 533 Million, https://kemenperin.go.id/artikel/22830/Serap-200-Ribu-Tenaga-Kerja,-Ekspor-Industri-Batik-Tembus-USD-533-Juta. (21 November 2022). (Text in Indonesian)
Tarei, P.K., Thakkar, J.J. & Nag. B., A Hybrid Approach for Quantifying Supply Chain Risk and Prioritizing The Risk Drivers: A Case of Indian Petroleum Supply Chain, Journal Manufacture Technology Management, 29(3), pp. 533?569, 2018.
Akbari, N., Jones, D. & Arabikhan, F., Goal Programming Models with Interval Coefficients for the Sustainable Selection of Marine Renewable Energy Projects in the UK, European Journal of Operation Research, 293(2), pp. 748-760, 2021.
Kilic, H.S. & Yalcin, A.S., Modified Two-Phase Fuzzy Goal Programming Integrated with IF-TOPSIS for Green Supplier Selection, Applied Soft Computing Journal, 93, 106371, 2020.
Govindaraju, R., Akbar, M.I., Gondodiwiryo, L. & Simatupang, T., The Application of a Decision-Making Approach Based on Fuzzy ANP and TOPSIS for Selecting a Strategic Supplier, Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences, 47(4), pp. 406-425, 2015.
Wichapa, N. & Khokhajaikiat, P., A Hybrid Multi-Criteria Analysis Model for Solving the Facility Location?Allocation Problem: A Case Study of Infectious Waste Disposal, Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences, 50(5), pp. 699-719, 2018.
Haruna, A., Shafiq, N., Ali, M.O., Mohammed, M. & Haruna, S., Design and Construction Technique for Low Embodied Energy Building: An Analytical Network Process Approach, Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences, 52(2), pp. 166-180, 2020.
Ding, Z., Fang. H., Yao, Z., Liu, J. & Wang, J., Research on Multi-criteria Material Selection of Automobile in Full Cycle under the Background of Green Manufacturing, Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 1910(1), 2021.
Gul, M., Celik, E., Gumus, A.T. & Guneri, A.F., A Fuzzy Logic Based PROMETHEE Method for Material Selection Problems, Beni-Suef University Journal Basic and Application Sciences, 7(1), pp. 68-79, 2018.
Maity, S.R. & Chakraborty, S., A Visual Decision Aid for Gear Materials Selection, Journal Institution of Engineering (India)Series C, 94, no. September, pp. 199-212, 2013.
Zindani, D. & Kumar, K., Material Selection for Turbine Seal Strips Using PROMETHEE-GAIA Method, Materials Today: Proceedings, 5(9), pp. 17533-17539, 2018/
Patnaik, P.K., Swain, P.T.R., Mishra, S.K., Purohit, A. & Biswas, S., Composite Material Selection for Structural Applications Based on AHP-MOORA Approach, Materials Today: Proceedings, 33, pp. 5659-5663, 2020.
Agrawal, R., Sustainable Material Selection for Additive Manufacturing Technologies: A Critical Analysis of Rank Reversal Approach, Journal of Cleaner Production, 296, 126500, 2021.
Saivaew, N. & Butdee. S., Decision Making for Effective Assembly Machined Parts Selection Using Fuzzy AHP and Fuzzy Logic, Materials Today: Proceedings, 26, pp. 2265-2271, 2019.
Torkayesh, A.E., Malmir, B. & Asadabadi, M.R., Sustainable Waste Disposal Technology Selection: The Stratified Best-Worst Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Method, Waste Management, 122, pp. 100-112, 2021.
Ramnath. R.A., Thyla, P.R. & Harishsharran, A.K.R., Machining Parameter Selection In Milling Epoxy Granite Composites Based on AHP, Materials Today: Proceedings, 42, pp. 319-324, 2020.
Mathew, M., Chakrabortty, R.K. & Ryan, M.J., A Novel Approach Integrating AHP and TOPSIS Under Spherical Fuzzy Sets for Advanced Manufacturing System Selection, Engineering Applications of Artificial Intelligence, 96. October, 103988, 2020.
Pham, T.T. & Nguyen, C.N., Adaptive Fuzzy Proportional Integral Sliding Mode Control for Two-Tank Interacting System, Journal of Engineering and Technological Sciences, 54(3), 220310, 2022.
Hastuti, L.S.S. & Pristiwati, E., Techno Economics of Wooden Stamp Canting,? Dinamika Kerajinan dan Batik:Majalah Ilmiah, 27(1), pp. 9-20, 2010.
Prasetyo, R. & Wibisono, M.A., Development of Stamp Cantings Made from Multiplex for Make to Order Case Study in Stamped Batik Production, in Prosiding Seminar Nasional Aplikasi Sains & Teknologi, 000, no. September, pp. 147-155, 2018. (Text in Indonesian)
Nurohmad, N. & Eskak, E., Duplex Paper Waste for Batik Canting Stamp Material, Dinamika Kerajinan dan Batik:Majalah Ilmiah, 36(2), pp. 125?134, 2019.
Hamidi, K., Wibisono, M.A. & Dharma, I.G.B.B., Development of a Stamp Canting Made of Plastic Using Additive Manufacturing Technology, in Prosiding Seminar Nasional Teknik Industri Universitas Gadjah Mada, 2017. (Text in Indonesian)
Love, L.B., Beautiful Batik: What it is & How it?s Made, Blogspot, https://dishfunctionaldesigns.blogspot.com/2012/08/beautiful-batik-what-is-batik-how-its.html. (09-Feb-2023)
Suryanto, S., Suharto. S., Priyo, V.T., Sarana, S., Hermawan, I. & Suwondo A., Making of Stamped Batik by Machined Batik Stamp Pattern Made from Hand Made Design Batik Image, International Journal Innovative Research in Advanced Engineering, 3(3), pp. 24-27, 2016.
Muyasda, I. & Wibisono, M.A., Development of Aluminum Stamp Canting Tool using Subtracting Process, Undergraduate Thesis, Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering, Gadjah Mada University, 2014.
Hidayat, S.R., Affanti. T.B., Josef, A.I. & Nurcahyanti, D., Batik Stamp Canting Made of Waste Paper Material as A Frugal Innovation In Batik, IOP Conf. Ser. Earth Environ. Sci., 905(1), 2021.
Suharto, S., Suryanto, S., Tri, P.V., Sarana, S., Iwan, H. & Suwondo, A., Alternative Material for Making Batik Cap Canting (CBC), Prosiding SNST, 2014.
Milosavljevic, M., Bursac, M. & Trickovic, G., Selection of The Railroad Container Terminal in Serbia Based on Multi Criteria Decision-Making Methods, Decision Making: Applications in Management and Engineering, 1(2), pp. 1-15, 2018.
Velasques, M. & Hester, P.T., An Analysis of Multi-Criteria Decision Making Methods, Int. J. Oper. Res., 10(2), pp. 56-66, 2013.
Taherdoost, H. & Madanchian, M., Multi-Criteria Decision Making (MCDM) Methods and Concepts, Encyclopedia, 3(1), pp. 77-87, 2023.
Saxena, P., Pagone, R., Salonitis, K. & Jolly, M.R., Sustainability Metrics for Rapid Manufacturing of the Sand Casting Moulds: A Multi-Criteria Decision-Making Algorithm-Based Approach, Journal of Cleaner Production, 311, no. January, p. 127506, 2021.
Qin, X.S. & Lin, Q.G., A MCDM-based Expert System for Climate-change Impact Assessment and Adaptation Planning ? A Case Study for the Georgia Basin , Canada, Expert Systems with Applications, 34, pp. 2164-2179, 2008.
Simanaviciene, R. & Ustinovichius, L., Sensitivity Analysis for Multiple Criteria Decision Making Methods: TOPSIS and SAW, Procedia ? Social and Behavior Sciences, 2(6), pp. 7743-7744, 2010.
Brans, J.P. & Vincke, P., Note ? A Preference Ranking Organization Method, No. June 2022, 1985.
Brans, J.P., Vinckle, P. & Mareschal, B., How to Select and How to Rank Projects: The PROMETHEE Method, Euopean Journal of Operation Research, 24, pp. 228-238, 1986.
Tuzkaya, G., Gulsun, B., Kahraman, C. & Ozgen, D., An Integrated Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Decision Making Methodology for Material Handling Equipment Selection Problem and An Application, Expert Systems with Applications, 37, pp. 2853-2863, 2010.
Alauddin, S,M., Ismail, I., Zaili, F.S., Ilias, N.F. & Aripin, N.F.K., Electrical and Mechanical Properties of Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene/Graphene Platelet Nanocomposite, Materials Today: Proceedings, 5, pp. S125-S129, 2018.
Salim, M.A., Termiti, Z.H. & Saad, A.M., Mechanical Properties on ABS/PLA Materials for Geospatial Imaging Printed Product Using 3D Printer Technology, Elsevier Ltd., 2019.
Sotoudeh-Anvari, S., Sadjadi, S.J., S. Molana, M.H. & Sadi-Nezhad, S., A New MCDM-Based Approach Using BWM And SAW for Optimal Search Model, Decision Science Letter, 7(4), pp. 395-404, 2018.
Abdel-Basset, M. & Mohamed, R., A Novel Plithogenic TOPSIS ? CRITIC Model for Sustainable Supply Chain Risk Management, Journal of Cleaner Production, 247, 119586, 2020.
Akhouri, D., Banerjee, D., & Mishra, S.B., A Review Report on The Plating Process of Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM) Built Parts, Materials Today: Proceedings, 26, Part. 2, pp. 2140-2142, 2020.
