The Application of a Decision-making Approach based on Fuzzy ANP and TOPSIS for Selecting a Strategic Supplier
AbstractSupplier selection becomes very important when used in the context of strategic partnerships because of the long-term orientation of the relationship. This paper describes the application of a decision-making approach for selecting a strategic partner (supplier). The approach starts with defining a set of criteria that fits the company's condition. In the next steps, a combination of fuzzy-ANP and TOPSIS methods is used to determine the weight for each criterion and rank all the alternatives. The application of the approach in an Indonesian manufacturing company showed that the three factors that got the highest weight were "geographical location", "current operating performance", and "reliability". Geographical location got the highest weight because it affects many other factors such as reaction to changes in demand, after-sales service, and delivery lead-time. Application of the approach helps decision-makers to gain effectiveness and efficiency in the decision-making process because it facilitates them to express their group's collective preferences while also providing opportunities for members to express their individual preferences. Future research can be directed at combining qualitative and quantitative criteria to develop the best criteria and methods for the selection of the best suppliers based on fuzzy ANP and TOPSIS.
Liao, C.-N. & Kao, H.-P., An Integrated Fuzzy TOPSIS and MCGP Approach to Supplier Selection in Supply Chain Management, Expert Systems with Applications, 38, pp. 10803-10811, 2011.
Keskin, G., Ilhan, S. & Ozkan, C., The Fuzzy ART Algorithm: A Categorization Method for Supplier Evaluation and Selection, Expert Systems with Applications, 37(2), pp. 1235-1240, 2010.
Weber, C., Benton, W. & Current, J., Vendor Selection Criteria and Methods, European of Journal of Operational Research, 50(1), pp. 2-18, 1991.
Liu, F. & Hai, H., The Voting Analytic Hierarchy Process Method for Selecting Supplier, International Journal of Production Economics, 97, pp. 308-317, 2005.
Onut, S., Kara, S. S. & Isik, E., Long Term Supplier Selection Using a Combined Fuzzy MCDM Approach: A Case, Expert Systems with Applications, 36, pp. 3887-3895, 2009.
Minahan, T., Is Partnering A Shame? Purchasing, June 4, pp. 68-59, 1998.
Kannan, V. & Tan, K., Buyer-Supplier Relationships: The Impact of Supplier Selection and Buyer-Supplier Engagement on Relationship and Firm Performance, International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Managements, 36(10), pp. 775-775, 2006.
Ellram, L.M., The Supplier Selection Decision in Strategic Partnerships,Journal of Purchasing and Material Managements, 26(4), pp. 8-11, 1990.
Wu, D., Performance Evaluation: An Integrated Method Using Data Envelopment Analysis And Fuzzy Preference Relations, European Journal of Operational Research, 194(1), pp. 227-235, 2009.
He, S., Chaundhry, S., Lei, Z. & Baohua, W., Stochastic Vendor Selection Problem: Chance-Constrained Model and Genetic Algorithms, Annals of Operations Research, 168(1), pp. 169-179, 2009.
Sevkli, M., Koh, S., Zaim, S., Damirbag, M. & Tatoglu, E., An Application of Data Envelopment Analytic Hierarchy Process for Supplier Selection: A Case Study of BEKO in Turke, International Journal of Production Research, 45(9), pp. 1973-2003, 2007.
Chan, F. & Kumar, N., Global Supplier Development Considering Risk Factors Using Fuzzy Extended. AHP-Based Approach, Omega, 35(4), pp.417-431, 2007.
Lee, S., Mogi, G. & Kim, J., Decision Support for Prioritizing Energy Technologies Against High Oil Prices: A Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process Approach, J Loss Prev Process Ind, pp. 915-920, 2009.
Rao, P. & Holt, D., Do Green Supply Chains Lead To Competitiveness And Economic Performance? International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 25(9), pp. 898-916, 2005.
Kumar, M., Vrat, P. & Shankar, R., A Fuzzy Programming Approach for Vendor Selection Problem in a Supply Chain. International Journal of Production Economics, 101(2), pp. 273-285, 2006.
Tsai, W. & Hung, S.-J., A Fuzzy Goal Programming Approach for Green Supply Chain Optimisation under Activity-Based Costing and Performance Evaluation with a Value-Chain Structure. International Journal of Production Research, 47(18), pp. 4991-5017, 2009.
Gencer, C. & Gurpinar, D., Analytic Network Process in Supplier Selection: A Case Study in an Electronic Firm. Applied Mathematical Modelling, 31, pp. 2475-2486, 2007.
Lin, R., An Integrated FANP-MOLP for Supplier Evaluation And Order Allocation, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 33, pp. 2730-2736, 2009.
Tuzkaya, U.R. & Onut, S., A Fuzzy Analytic Network Process Based Approach to Transportation-Mode Selection Between Turkey And Germany: A Case Study, Information Sciences, 178(15), pp. 3133-3146, 2008.
Vinodh, S., Ramiya, R. & Gautham, S., Application of Fuzzy Analytic Network Process for Supplier Selection in Manufacturing Organisation, Expert Systems with Applications, 38, pp. 272-280, 2011.
Liao, C.-N. & Kao, H.-P., Supplier Selection Model Using Taguchi Loss Function, Analytical Hierarchy Process and Multi-Choice Goal Programming, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 58(4), pp. 571-577, 2010.
Kannan, D., Khodaverdi, R., Olfat, L., Jafarian, A. & Diabat, A.,Integrated Fuzzy Multi Criteria Decision-making Method and MultiObjective Programming Approach for Supplier Selection and Order Allocation in Green Supply Chain, Journal of Cleaner Production, 47, pp. 355-367, 2013.
Zeydan, M., Colpan, C. & Cobaniglu, C., A Combined Methodology for Supplier Selection and Performance Evaluation, Expert Systems with Applications, 38, pp. 2741-2751, 2011.
B1/4y1/4kzkan, G. & ifi, G., A Novel Hybrid MCDM Approach Based on Fuzzy DEMATEL, Fuzzy-ANP and Fuzzy TOPSIS to Evaluate Green Suppliers, Expert Systems with Applications: An International Journal, 39(3), pp. 3000-3011, 2012.
Ho, W., Xu, X. & Dey, P., Multi-Criteria Decision-making Approaches for Supplier Evaluation and Selection: A Literature Review, European Journal of Operational Research, 202, pp. 16-24, 2010.
Wu, C. & Barnes, D., A Literature Review of Decision-Making Models And Approaches for Partner Selection in Agile Supply Chains,Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 17(4), pp. 256-274, 2011.
Chai, J., Liu, J. & Ngai, E., Application of Decision-Making Techniques in Supplier Selection: A Systematic Review of Literature, Expert Systems
with Applications, 40, pp. 3872-3885, 2013.
Saaty, T., Fundamentals of Decision-making and Priority Theory With The Analytic Hierarchy Process. Pittsburgh: RWS Publications, 2000.
Ayag, Z. & Ozdemir, R.G., Evaluating Machine Tool Alternatives Through Modified TOPSIS and Alpha-Cut Based Fuzzy-ANP, International Journal Production Economics, 140, pp. 630-636, 2012.
Garfamy, R.M., Supplier Selection and Business Process Improvement, Doctoral thesis, Business Economics Department, Postgraduate School, Autonomous University of Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain, 2005.
Sarkar, A. & Mohapatra, P., Evaluation of Supplier Capability and Performance: A Method for Supply Base Reduction, Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management, 12(3), pp. 148-163, 2006.
Shen, C.-Y. & Yu, K.-T., Enhancing the Efficacy of Supplier Selection Decision-Making on the Initial Stage of New Product Development: A Hybrid Fuzzy Approach Considering the Strategic and Operational Factors Simultaneously, Expert Systems with Applications, pp. 11271-11281, 2009.
Shahgholian, K., Shahraki, A., Vaezi, Z. & Hajihosseini, H., A Model for Supplier Selection Based on Fuzzy Multi-Criteria Group Decisionmaking, African Journal of Business Management, 6(20), pp. 6254-6265, 2012.
Chan, F., Kumar, N., Tiwari, M., Lau, H. & Choy, K., Global Supplier Selection: A Fuzzy-AHP Approach, International Journal of Production Research, 46(14), pp. 3823-2857, 2008.
Larson, P.D., Buyer-Supplier Co-Operation, Product Quality and Total Costs, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, 24(6), pp. 4-10, 1994.
Tracey, M. & Tan, C.L., Empirical Analysis of Supplier Selection and Involvement, Customer Satisfaction, and Firm Performance,Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 6(4), pp. 174-188, 2001.
Dzever, S., Merdji, M. & Saives, A.L., Purchase Decision-making and Buyer-Seller Relationship Development in the French Food Processing Industry, Supply Chain Managment, 6(5), pp. 216-229, 2001.
Choi, T.Y. & Hartley, J.L., An Exploration of Supplier Selection Practices Across the Supply Chain, Journal of Operations Management, 14(4), pp. 333-343, 1996.
Kotabe, M. & Murray, J.Y., Outsourcing Service Activities, Journal of Marketing Management, 10(1), pp. 40-45, 2001.
Shahadat, K., Supplier Choice Criteria of Executing Agencies in Developing Countries, International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 16(4), pp. 261-285, 2003.
Rezaei, J. & Ortt, R., Multi-Criteria Supplier Segmentation Using a Fuzzy Preference Relations Based AHP, European Journal of Operational Research, 226, pp. 75-84, 2013.
Humphreys, P., Mak, K.L. & Yeung, C.M., A Just-In-Time Evaluation Strategy for International Procurement, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 3(4), pp. 175-186, 1998.
Chang, B., Chang, C.-W. & Wu, C.-H., Fuzzy DEMATEL Method for Developing Supplier Selection Criteria, Expert Systems with Applications, 38, pp. 1850-1858, 2011.
Handfield, R.B., US Global Sourcing: Patterns of Development. International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 14(6),
pp. 40-51, 1994.
Min, H., International Supplier Selection: A Multi-Attribute Utility Approach. International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistic
Management, 24(5), pp. 24-33, 1994.
Bevilacqua, M. & Petroni, A., From Traditional Purchasing to Supplier Management: A Fuzzy Logic-Based Approach To Supplier Selection,
International Journal of Logistics: Research and Applications, 5(3), pp. 235-255, 2002.
Bharadwaj, N., Investigating the Decision Criteria Used In Electronic Components Procurement, Industrial Marketing Management, 33(4), pp.
Roshandel, J., Miri-Nargesi, S. & Hatami-Shirkouh, L., Evaluating And Selecting the Supplier in Detergent Production Industry Using
Hierarchical Fuzzy TOPSIS, Applied Mathematical Modelling, 37, pp. 10170-10818, 2013.
Goffin, K., Szwejczewski, M. & New, C., Managing Suppliers: When Fewer Can Mean More, International Journal of Physical Distribution and Logistics Management, 27(7), pp. 422-435,1997.
Pearson, J.N. & Ellram, L.M., Supplier Selection and Evaluation in Small Versus Large Electronics Firms, Journal of Small Business Management,
(4), pp. 53-65, 1995.
Noordwier, T.G., John, G. & Nevin, J.R., Performance Outcome of Purchasing Arrangements in Industrial Buyer-Vendor Relationships, Journal of Marketing, October, pp. 80-93, 1990.
Bhutta, K.S. & Huq, F., Supplier Selection Problem: A Comparison of the Total Cost of Ownership and Analytics Hierarchy Process Approaches, Supply Chain Management: An International Journal, 7(3), pp. 126-135, 2002.
Shyur, H.-J. & Shih, H.-S., A Hybrid MCDM Model for Strategy Vendor Selection. Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 44, pp. 749-761, 2006.
Tam, M.C. & Tummala, V. R. An Application of the AHP in Vendor Selection of a Telecommunications System. Omega -The International
Journal of Management Science, 29(2), pp. 171-182, 2001.
Verma, R. & Pullman, M.E., An Analysis of the Supplier Selection Process. Omega, 26(6), pp. 739-750, 1998.
Dursun, M. & Karsak, E., A QFD-Based Fuzzy MCDM Approach for Supplier Selection. Applied Mathematical Modelling, 37, pp. 5964-5875, 2013.
Onder, E. & Dag, S., Combining Analytical Hierarchy Process and TOPSIS Approaches for Supplier Selection in a Cable Company. Journal of Businees, Economics & Finance, 2(2), pp. 56-74, 2013.
Bharadwaj, N., Investigating the Decision Criteria Used in Electronic Components Procurement, Industrial Marketing Management, 33(4), pp.317-323, 2004.
Chu, T.-C. & Varma, R., Evaluating Suppliers via a Multiple Levels Multiple Criteria Decision-making Method under Fuzzy Environment, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 62, pp. 653-652, 2012.
Dyer, R. & Forman, E., Group Decision Support with the Analytic Hierarchy Process, Decision Support Systems, 8, pp. 99-124, 1992.
Lehpamer, H., RFID Design Principles. Norwood, MA: Artech House, 2012.
Elanchezhian, C., Ramnath, B. & Kesavan, R., Vendor Evaluation Using Multi Criteria Decision-making Technique, International Journal of Computer Applications, 5(9), pp. 4-9, 2010.
Mitchell, K. & Wasil, E., The Analytical Hierarchy Process, Applications, and Studies, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1989.
Matsatsinis, N., Grigoroudis, E. & Samaras, A., Aggregation and Disaggregation of Preferences for Collective Decision-Making, Group Decision and Negotiation, 14, pp. 217-232, 2005.
Kasirian, M.N. & Yusuff, R.M., Determining Interdependencies among Supplier Selection Criteria, European Journal of Scientific Research, 35(1), pp. 76-84, 2009.
Saaty, T.L., Some Mathematical Concepts of the Analytic Hierarchy Process, Behaviormetrika, 29, pp. 1-9, 1991.
Chang, Y.-H., Yeh, C.-H. & Chang, Y.-W., A New Method Selection Approach for Fuzzy Group Multicriteria Decision-making, Applied Soft Computing, 13, pp. 2179-2187, 2013.
Razmi, J., Rafiei, H. & Hashemi, M., Designing A Decision Support System to Evaluate and Select Suppliers Using Fuzzy Analytic Network Process, Computer & Industrial Engineering, 57, pp. 1282-1290, 2009.
Hwang, C. & Yoon, K., Multiple Attribute Decision-making: Methods and Applications, New York: Springer-Verlag, 1981.
Shih, H., Shyur, H. & Lee, E., An Extension of TOPSIS for Group Decision-making, Mathematical and Computer Modelling, 45(7-8), pp. 801-813, 2011.