Planning Transportation Megaprojects: Paradoxes and Challenges in Planning Complex Projects

Authors

  • Susanti Widiastuti Doctoral Program, School of Architecture, Planning and Policy Development, Bandung Institute of Technology Jl. Ganesha 10, Bandung, 40132, West Java, Indonesia
  • Haryo Winarso School of Architecture, Planning, and Policy Development, Faculty of Urban Regional Planning, Bandung Institute of Technology Jl.Ganesha 10, Bandung,40132, Jawa Barat, Indonesia
  • Petrus Natalivan Indradjati School of Architecture, Planning, and Policy Development, Faculty of Urban Regional Planning, Bandung Institute of Technology Jl.Ganesha 10, Bandung,40132, Jawa Barat, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5614/jpwk.2022.33.2.2

Keywords:

Complexity, Non-linear Planning, Open System, Transportation Megaproject, Uncertainty

Abstract

Transportation megaprojects have become a routine feature in the development of cities and urban infrastructure. The failure of many megaprojects to achieve the desired performance levels is an issue that has been discussed in several studies in recent years, ascribing it to the inability to plan for complexity and uncertainty. This and other problems that are commonplace among megaprojects are yet to be solved despite the employment of highly experienced professionals and resources. The role of the decision-making process in the planning phase is critical in dealing with the complex and uncertain nature of megaprojects. This paper presents a review of literature related to this topic and argues that a major challenge in the planning phase is a cultural misunderstanding of transportation megaprojects, since the rationale behind the development decisions and planning approaches fails to manage complexity and uncertainty. In this study, we identified four paradoxes that occur in transportation megaproject practice that show that top-down and linear planning approaches should be reformed to become more open-minded, nonlinear, and open. Doing so may benefit regional development and broad communities in the future.

References

Atkinson, R. (1999) Project Management: Cost, Time and Quality, Two Best Guesses and Phenomenon, It?s Time to Accept Other Success Criteria. International Journal of Project Management 17(6), 337?342.

Altshuler, A and Luberoff, D. (2003). Mega Project: The Changing Politics of Urban and Public Investment. Washington: Brookings Institution Press Another reference.

APM (2008). APM competence framework. Association for Project Management, Bucks. UK.

Baccarini, D. (1996) The Concept of Project Complexity ? A Review. International Journal of Project Management 14(4), 201?204.

Banister, D. and Hall, P. (1993) The Age of The Train. Built Environment 19(3), 156-162.

Boateng, P., Chen, Z., & Ogunlana, S. O. (2015) An analytical network process model for risks prioritization in megaprojects. International Journal of Project Management 33(8), 1795? 1811.

Bertolini, L. (2010) Complex System Evolutionary Planning, in De Roo & Silva (2010) A Planner in Counter with Complexity (eds), England: Ashgate.

Brockmann, C., Girmscheid, G. (2007) The Inherent Complexity of Large-Scale Engineering Projects. Project Perspectives 29, 22-26.

Chapman, R.J. (1998) The role of systems dynamics in understanding the impact of changes to key project personnel on design production within construction projects. International Journal of Project Management 16 (4), 235?247.

Chapman, R.J. (2016) A framework of the Dimensions and Characteristics of Complexity Inherent within Rail Megaprojects. International Journal of Project Management 34, 937-956.

Capka, J.R. (2004) Megaproject ? They Are Different Breed. Public Road 68 (1).

De Roo, G. (2001) ?Complexity as a criterion for decision making; a theoretical perspective for complex (urban) conflicts. Paper presented at the 1st World Planning School Congress at the College of Architecture and Urban Planning, Shanghai, July 2001.

De Roo, G. & Silva, E. (2010). A Planner?s Encounter with Complexity. England: Ashgate.

Dimitriou, H. T., Ward, E. J., & Wright, P. G (2013) Mega transport projects - Beyond the ?iron triangle?: Findings from the OMEGA research program. Progress in Planning 86, 1-43.

Dimitriou, H. T. (2012). Institutions and Governance for Urban Mobility. Draft Report for Global Report on Human Settlements, Chapter 9. Nairobi: UN-Habitat.

Delphine., Witte, P. & Spit, T. (2020). Bridging the Perception Gap? When Top-Down Built megaprojects meet bottom-up perception: A Case Study of Suramadu Bridge, Indonesia. Draft Report for Global Report on Human Settlements, Chapter 9. Nairobi: UN-Habitat.

Eweje, J., Turner, R., & Mler, R. (2012) Maximizing strategic value from megaprojects: The influence of information-feed on decision-making by the project manager. International Journal of Project Management 30(6), 639?65.

Erkul, M., Yitmen, I., Celik, T. (2020) Dynamics of Stakeholder Engagement in Mega Transport Infrastructure. Projects International Journal of Managing Projects in Business 13(7),1465-1495.

Fainstein and Fainstein (1982) Debates in Urban Planning: The Impact of Marxism Theory within the United States, in Paris, C., Critical Readings in Planning Theory, Oxford: Pergamon Press.

Fainstein, S. (2008) Mega Projects in New York, London and Amsterdam. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32(4): 769-785.

Forester, J. (1989). Planning in The Face of Power. University of California Press. Faludi, A. (1973) A Reader in Planning Theory. Oxford: Pergamon Press.

Flyvbjerg, B., Bruzelius, N., & Rothengatter, W. (2003). Megaprojects and risk: an anatomy of Ambition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2009) Survival of the unfit test: Why the worst infrastructure gets built ? and what we can do about it. Oxford Review of Economic Policy 25(3), 344?367.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2011). Over budget, over time, over and over again: Managing major projects. In The Oxford handbook of project management. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Flyvbjerg, B. (2014) What you should know about megaprojects and why: An overview. Project Management Journal 45(2), 6?19.

Flyvbjerg, B., Skamris holm, M.K., Buhl, S.L (2004) What causes cost overrun in transport infrastructure projects? Transp. Rev. 23, 71-88.

Giezen, M. (2012) Keeping it simple? A case study into the advantages and disadvantages of reducing complexity in mega project planning. International Journal of Project Management 30(7), 781?790.

Gellert, P.K. and Lynch, B.D. (2004) Mega-Project as displacements. International Social Science Journal 55(175), 15-25.

Healey, P. (1992) Planning through debate: The communicative turn in planning theory. Town Planning Review 63(2), 143-162.

Healey, P. and Hillier, J. (1995) The Communicative Turn in Planning Theory and Its Implications for Spatial Strategy Formation. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design 23(2), 217-234.

He, Q., Luo, L., Hu, Y., & Chan, A. P. C. (2015) Measuring the complexity of mega construction projects in China?A fuzzy analytic network process analysis. International Journal of Project Management 33(3), 549?563.

Huelin R., Iheaanacho, I., Payne, K., Sandman, K. (2015) What?s in a Name? Systematic and Non-Systematic Literature Reviews, and Why the Distinction Matters. The Evidence Forum. Access from https://www.evidera.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Whats-in-a-Name-Systematic-and-Non-Systematic-Literature-Reviews-and-Why-the-Distinction-Matters.pdf on 15 january 2022.

Hammersley M. (2006) Systematic or Unsystematic, Is that the Question? Reflections on the Science, Art, and Politics of Reviewing Research Evidence. Paper presented at the Public Health Evidence Steering Group of the Health Development Agency, October.

Innes, J.E., Booher, D.E. (2010). Planning with Complexity: An introduction to Collaborative Rationality for Public Policy. London: Routledge.

Jgensen, M., Halkjelsvik, T., Kitchenham, B. (2012) How Does Project Size Affect Cost Estimation Error? Statistical artifacts and Methodological Challenges. International Journal of Project Management 30, 839?849.

Lindblom, C.E. (1959) The Science of Muddling Through. In: Campbell, S& S. Fainstein (Ed.) (1996) Readings in Planning Theory, 288-304. Malden & Oxford: Blackwell Publisher.

Lehrer, U. and Laidley, J. (2008) Old Mega-Project Newly Package? Waterfront Redevelopment in Toronto. International Urban and Regional Research 32(4), 786-803.

Lane, B.G. (2017). Governance of Inclusive Transit-Oriented Development in Brazil. Working Paper.

MPA (2013). The Major Projects Authority Annual Report. Major Projects Authority London.

Morris, P.W.G. and Hough, G.H. (1987). The Anatomy of Major Projects?A Study of the Reality of Project Management. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

Mi?i?, S., Radujkovi?, M. (2015) Critical drivers of megaproject success and failure. Procedia Engineering 122, 71?80.

Muromachi, Y., Iwakura, S., Itaya, K., Otsuka, H., & Ohta, K. (2010) Kyushu Shingkansen Report. Tokyo Institute of Technology.

Moulaert, F., Swyngedouw, E., & Rodriguez, A. (2002) Neoliberal Urbanization in Europe: Large Scale Urban Development Projects and The New Urban Policy. Antipode 34(3), 547?582.

PMI (2013). A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge. Project Management Institute.

Ourueta, F. and Fainstein, S. (2008) The New Mega Projects: Genesis and Impact. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 32(4), 759-767.

OMEGA Centre. (2012) Mega projects: executive summary ? Lessons for decision-makers: An analysis of selected international large-scale transport infrastructure projects. OMEGA Centre, University College London.

Peters, D., & Novy, J. (2012) Train station area development mega-projects in Europe: Towards a typology. Built Environment 38(1), 13?30.

Pollack, J., Biesenthal, C., Sankaran, S., & Clegg, S. (2018). Classics in Megaproject management: A Structured Analysis of Three Major Works. International Journal of Project Management, 36(2), 372?384.

Pinto, J. K., Winch, G. (2016) The Unsettling of ?Settled Science:? The Past and Future of The Management of Projects. International Journal of Project Management 34 (2), 237?245.

Priemus, H., Flyvbjerg, B., Van Wee, B. (Ed.) (2008) Decision-making on Megaprojects: Costbenefit Analysis, Planning, and Innovation. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar.

Rothengatter, W. (2019) Megaprojects in Transportation Networks. Transport Policy 75, A1 - A15.

Rocha, L. (2014) Beyond Project Decision: Deciding on How to Decide. Social and Behavioral Sciences 119, 40-45.

Scott, J. (1998). Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Salet, W. (2008) Rethinking urban projects: Experiences in Europe. Urban Studies 45(11), 2343?2363.

Soderlund, J., Sankaran, S., and Biesenthal, C. (2018) The Past and Present of Megaprojects. Project Management Journal 48(6), 5-16.

Salet W., Bertolini L., and Giezen, M. (2013) Complexity and Uncertainty: Problem or Asset in Decision Making of Mega Infrastructure Projects? Complexity and Uncertainty in Mega Infrastructure Projects. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 37 (4), 198? 200.

Del Cerro Santamaria, G. (Ed.) (2013) Urban Megaprojects: A Worldwide View. Bingley: Emerald Group Publishing Limited.

Williams, T., Samset, K. (2010) Issues in front-end decision making on projects. Project Management Journal 41(2), 38 - 49.

Webber, M. (1973). Toward an AIP Consensus on the Profession's Roles and Purposes. In: Faludi, A (1987) A Decision ? Centered View of Environmental Planning. Oxford: Pergamon Press.

Webster, J. and Watson, R. T. (2002). Analyzing the past to prepare for the future: Writing a literature review. Management Information Systems Quarterly 26 (2), 13 ? 23.

Downloads

Published

2022-08-27

Issue

Section

Research Articles