Automotive Design Sketching in Teams: A Systematic Review
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5614/j.vad.2024.16.1.1Keywords:
automotive design, collaborative, communication, creativity, ROSES, sketchingAbstract
Automotive design sketching is crucial in the creative process, especially during conceptual design, as it facilitates shared understanding among design teams. Despite its significance, there need to be more comprehensive review papers addressing automotive design sketching in team settings. This systematic review aims to bridge this gap by identifying trends and evidence related to automotive design sketching within team settings. Employing the ROSES review flow diagram, five electronic databases ? Scopus, Web of Science, Science Direct, SAGE, and Google Scholar ? were utilized to search for relevant literature. Among the 902 non-duplicated articles initially screened, 17 studies from the past decade (2013-2023) underwent a thorough review and were integrated into the analysis. The findings emphasize the importance of team sketching, highlighting collaboration, communication, and creativity as essential values for enhancing shared understanding and design outcomes within teams. Significantly, the review uncovered a shortage of articles in recent years that encompass all three elements within a single study. This paper highlights the critical role of sketching in team-based automotive design and advocates for further research to investigate collaboration, communication, and creativity comprehensively. This knowledge is valuable for automotive designers, teams, and the industry, emphasizing the need for holistic approaches to optimize design processes and foster innovation.
References
Izatullayevna, Y.N., Factors of an Industrial Design, Types of its Origin and Purpose, Texas Journal of Multidisciplinary Studies, 8, pp. 172-174, 2022.
Ekblom, P., Designing Products Against Crime, Handbook of Crime Prevention and Community Safety, Tilley, N., ed., Willan, 2013.
Pahl, A.K., Newnes, L. & McMahon, C., A Generic Model for Creativity and Innovation: Overview for Early Phases of Engineering Design. Journal of Design Research, 6(1-2), pp. 5-44. 2007.
Haynes, P. & Yang, S., Supersystem Digital Twin-Driven Framework for New Product Conceptual Design, Advanced Engineering Informatics, 58, 102149, 2023.
Yusof, N., Karuppiah, K., Syahira, PA., Jamil, M., Rasdi, I., How, V., Sambasivan, S., Mani, K.K., Development and Initial Testing of Lumbar Support for Traffic Police Motorcycle Seat with Built-In Massager System: A Preliminary Study in The View of Ergonomics, Proceedings of the 4th European International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management Rome, Italy, 2021.
Ariff, N.S.N.A., Exploring the Role of Sketching on Shared Understanding in Design, Ph.D. dissertation, Delft University of Technology, 2020.
Gero, J.S. & Milovanovic, J., A Framework for Studying Design Thinking Through Measuring Designers? Minds, Bodies and Brains, Design Science, 6: e19, 2020.
Craft, B. & Cairns, P., Sketching Sketching: Outlines of a Collaborative Design Method, People and Computers XXIII Celebrating People and Technology, pp. 65-72, 2009.
Ariff, N., Eris, O. & Badke-Schaub, P., editors, How Designers Express Agreement, 5th IASDR Conference, 2013.
Ariff, N., Badke-Schaub, P., Eris, & Suib, S., editors, A Framework for Reaching Common Understanding During Sketching in Design Teams, Proceedings of DESIGN 2012, the 12th International Design Conference, 2012.
Badke-Schaub, P., Lauche, K., Neumann, A. & Ahmed, S., Task, Team, Process: The Development of Shared Representations in an Engineering Design Team, About Designing, McDonald, J. & Lloyd, P., eds., CRC Press, pp.153-170, 2022.
Kabir, M.A., Nandi, S.K., Suma, A, Y. & Ariff, N.S.N.A., Aquatic Weeds as Functional Ingredients for Aquaculture Feed Industry, Recent Advances, Challenges, Opportunities, New Product Development (NPD) and Sustainability, Agriculture Reports, 2(2), pp. 1-16, Aug. 2023.
Aslam, K., Chen, Y., Butt, M. & Malavolta, I., Cross-Platform Real-Time Collaborative Modeling, an Architecture and a Prototype Implementation via EMF, Cloud IEEE Access, May 2023.
Paay, J., Kjeldskov, J., Bnerup, M. & Rasenthiran, T., Sketching and Context: Exploring Creativity in Idea Generation Groups, Design Studies 84, 101159, Jan. 2023.
Li, T. & Zhan, Z., A Systematic Review on Design Thinking Integrated Learning in K-12 Education, Applied Sciences, 12(16), 8077, Aug. 2022.
Gong, Z., Lee, L.H., Soomro, S.A., Nanjappan, V. & Georgiev, G.V., A Systematic Review of Virtual Brainstorming from the Perspective of Creativity: Affordances, Framework and Outlook, Digital Creativity, 33(2), pp. 96-127, Apr. 2022.
Guinan, P.J., Parise, S. & Langowitz, N., Creating an Innovative Digital Project Team: Levers to Enable Digital Transformation, Business Horizons, 62(6), pp. 717-727, Dec. 2019.
Berg, L.P. & Vance, J.M., Industry use of Virtual Reality in Product Design and Manufacturing: A Survey, Virtual reality, 21, pp. 1-17, Mar. 2017.
Sun, L., Xiang, W., Chen, S. & Yang, Z., Collaborative Sketching in Crowdsourcing Design: A New Method for Idea Generation, International Journal of Technology and Design Education, 25, pp. 409-427, Aug. 2015.
Chandrasegaran, S., Badam, S.K., Zhao, Z., Elmqvist, N., Kisselburgh, L & Ramani, K., editors, Collaborative Sketching with skWiki: A Case Study, International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 2014.
Novov K., Jakubal, V., Achten, H. & Matejovska, D., editors, Collab Sketch: Case Study on Collaborative Sketching, Proceeding of the 31st International Conference on Education and research in Computer Aided Architectural Design in Europe, Faculty of Architecture, Delft University of Technology; eCAADe, Education, 2013.
Wu, T., Digital Project Management: Rapid Changes Define New Working Environments, Journal of Business Strategy, 43(5), pp. 323-331, 2022.
Mohamad Jamil, P.A.S., Mohammad Yusof, N.A.D., Karuppiah, K., Rasdi, I., How, V., Mohd Tamrin, S.B., Samsudin, M.H., Sambasivam, S. & Almutairi, N.S., Concept Development and Field Testing of Wireless Outdoor Indicator System for use in Monitoring Exposures at Work among Malaysian Traffic Police, Toxics, 11(4), Apr. 2023.
Ozturk, P., Avci, C. & Kaya, , The Effect of Remote Collaborative Work on Design Processes During the Pandemic, Strategic Design Research Journal, 14(1), Apr. 2021.
Cross, N., Design Thinking: Understanding How Designers Think and Work, Bloomsbury Publishing, 2023.
Ehsani, M., Singh, K.V., Bansal, H.O. & Mehrjardi, R.T., State of the Art and Trends in Electric and Hybrid Electric Vehicles, Proceedings of the IEEE, 109(6), pp. 967-984, Jun. 2021.
Bouchard, C., Camous, R. & Aoussat, A., Nature and Role of Intermediate Representations (IR) in the Design Process: Case Studies in Car Design, International Journal of Vehicle Design, 38(1), pp. 1-25, Jan. 2005.
Tovey, M., Porter, S. & Newman, R., Sketching, Concept Development and Automotive Design, Design studies, 24(2), pp. 135-153, Mar. 2003.
Muhammad, I., Mohd Hasnu, N.N. & Ekins, P., Empirical Research of Public Acceptance on Environmental Tax: A Systematic Literature Review, Environments, 8(10), 109, Oct. 2021.
Gusenbauer, M. & Haddaway, NR., Which Academic Search Systems are Suitable for Systematic Reviews or Meta?Analyses? Evaluating Retrieval Qualities of Google Scholar, Pubmed, and 26 Other Resources, Research Synthesis Methods, 11(2), pp. 181-217, Mar. 2020.
Haddaway, N.R., Macura, B., Whaley, P. & Pullin, A.S., ROSES RepOrting Standards for Systematic Evidence Syntheses: Pro Forma, Flow-Diagram and Descriptive Summary of the Plan and Conduct of Environmental Systematic Reviews and Systematic Maps, Environmental Evidence, 7, pp. 1-8, Mar. 2018.
Fakih, M., Klemp, O., Puch, S. & Grtner, K., A Modeling Methodology for Collaborative Evaluation of Future Automotive Innovations, Software and Systems Modeling, 20(5), pp. 1587-1608, 2021.
Shah, J.A., Lim, I., Molina-Cristobal, A., Dale, V. & Mei, F., editors, Learner?s Experience about Freehand Sketching Vs CAD for Concept Ideation Process During Product Design Development, International Conference on Engineering, Technology & Education (TALE), IEEE, 2021.
Hkki, T., Seitamaa-Hakkarainen, P. & Hakkarainen, K., Line by Line, Part by Part: Collaborative Sketching for Designing, International Journal of Technology and Design Education, 28, pp. 471-494, 2018.
Singh, B.K. & Luthra, M., editors, Freehand Sketching an Essential Tool for Unified Modelling Diagrams in Object Oriented Approaches, Second International Conference on Green Computing and Internet of Things (ICGCIoT), IEEE, 2018.
Nikoli?, M., ?kec, S., Martinec, T. & Horvat, N., editors, The Role of Sketching Activities and Outcomes in Conceptual Design Phase, Proceedings of the Design Society, International Conference on Engineering Design, Cambridge University Press, 2019.
Hammond, T., Kumar, S.P.A., Runyon, M., Cherian, J., Williford, B., Keshavabhotla, S., Valentine, S., Li, W., Linsey, J. It?s Not Just About Accuracy: Metrics that Matter when Modeling Expert Sketching Ability, ACM Transactions on Interactive Intelligent Systems (TIIS), 8(3), pp. 1-47, 2018.
Sandnes, F.E., Lianguzov, Y., Rodrigues, O.V., Lieng, H., Medola, F.O. & Pavel, N., editors, Supporting Collaborative Ideation Through Freehand Sketching of 3D-Shapes in 2D using Colour, Cooperative Design, Visualization and Engineering, Luo, Y., eds., Springer, pp. 123-134, 2017.
Yusoff, S.B.M., Hamdan, S. & Ibrahim, Z. Techniques and Sequence of Sketching in the Conceptual Phase of Automotive Design, Social Sciences, 8(14), pp. 108-116, 2018.
Mao, X., Galil, O., Parrish, Q. & Sen, C., Evidence of Cognitive Chunking in Freehand Sketching During Design Ideation, Design Studies, 67, pp. 1-26, 2020.
Galil, O.M., Martusevich, K. & Sen, C, A Protocol Study of Cognitive Chunking in Free-Hand Sketching During Design Ideation by Novice Designers, Design Computing and Cognition ?16, Gero, J., eds., Springer, pp. 115-134, 2017.
Hilton, E., Li, W., Newton, S.H., Alemdar, M., Pucha, R. & Linsey, J., The Development and Effects of Teaching Perspective Free-Hand Sketching in Engineering Design, Proceedings of the ASME 2016 International Design Engineering Technical Conferences and Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, American Society of Mechanical Engineers, 2016.
Shao, T., Li, W., Zhou, K., Xu, W., Guo, B. & Mitra, N.J., Interpreting Concept Sketches, ACM Transactions on Graphics (TOG), 32(4), pp. 1-10, 2013.
Van der Lugt, R., How Sketching Can Affect the Idea Generation Process in Design Group Meetings, Design studies, 26(2), pp. 101-122, 2005.
Supena, I., Darmuki, A. & Hariyadi, A., The Influence of 4C (Constructive, Critical, Creativity, Collaborative) Learning Model on Students? Learning Outcomes, International Journal of Instruction, 14(3), pp. 873-892, 2021.
Trotter, L., Mai, C. & Alt, F., CarSketch: A Collaborative Sketching Table with Self-Propelled Tangible Objects for Automotive Applications, Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on Automotive User Interfaces and Interactive Vehicular Applications Adjunct, pp. 126-130, 2017.
Schembri, M., Farrugia, P., Wodehouse, A.J., Grierson, H. & Kovacevic, A., Influence of Sketch Types on Distributed Design Team Work, CoDesign, 11(2), pp. 99-118, 2015.
Johansson?Skdberg, U., Woodilla, J. & tinkaya, M., Design Thinking: Past, Present and Possible Futures, Creativity and Innovation Management, 22(2), pp. 121-146, 2013.
Dell?Era, C., Magistretti, S., Cautela, C., Verganti, R. & Zurlo, F., Four Kinds of Design Thinking: From Ideating to Making, Engaging and Criticizing, Creativity and Innovation Management, 29(2), pp. 324-344, 2020.
Xu, P., Joshi, C.K. & Bresson, X., Multigraph Transformer for Free-Hand Sketch Recognition, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks and Learning Systems, 33(10), pp. 5150-5161, 2021.
Kari, Z.A., Sukri, S.A.M., Rusli, N.D., Mat, K., Mahmud, M., Zakaria, N.N., Wee, W., Hamid, N.K., Kabir, M.A., Ariff, N.S. & Abidin, S.Z., Recent Advances, Challenges, Opportunities, Product Development and Sustainability of Main Agricultural Wastes for the Aquaculture Feed Industry?A Review, Annals of Animal Science, 23(1), pp. 25-38. 2023.
Gero, J., Creation and Characterization of Design Spaces, Proceedings of Design Research Society, 2022.
Evans, M. & Aldoy, N., Digital Design Sketching using the Tablet PC, The Design Journal, 19(5), pp. 763-787, 2016.
Mountstephens, J. & Teo, J., Progress and Challenges in Generative Product Design: A Review of Systems, Computers, 9(4), pp. 80, 2020.
Tovey, M., Drawing and CAD in Industrial Design, Design Studies, 10(1), pp. 24-39, 1989.
Yoo, S., Lee, S., Kim, S., Hwang, K.H., Park, J.H. & Kang, N., Integrating Deep Learning into CAD/CAE System: Generative Design and Evaluation of 3D Conceptual Wheel, Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, 64(4), pp. 2725-2747, 2021.
Ranscombe, C., Rodda, J. & Johnson, M., Visualising User Experiences: Analysing Embodiment of UX in Autonomous Vehicle Concepts, Proceedings of the Design Society: International Conference on Engineering Design, Cambridge University Press, 2019.
Company, F.M., Ford Collaboration with Gravity Sketch Introduces Co-Creation Feature, Allowing Designers Across Globe to Work in Same Virtual Reality Space, Ford Media, https://media.ford.com/content/fordmedia/fna/us/en/news/2019/05/06/ford-collaboration-gravity-sketch-co-creation.html, (6 October 2023).
Sturdee, M., Robinson, S. & Linehan, C., Research Journeys: Making the Invisible, Visual, Proceedings of the 2020 ACM Designing Interactive Systems Conference, 2020.
Eppler, M.J. & Kernbach, S., Dynagrams: Enhancing Design Thinking Through Dynamic Diagrams, Design Studies, 7, pp. 91-117, 2016.
Rous, B.S. & Nash, J.B., Visual Communication as Knowledge Management in Design Thinking, The Handbook of Applied Communication Research, O?Hair, H.D. & O?Hair, M.J., eds., Wiley Online Library, pp. 233-248, 2020.
