Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Discussion

JICTRA / JOURNAL POLICIES
Corrections, Retractions, and Post-Publication Discussion
Journal of ICT Research and Applications
Commitment to the Integrity of the Scholarly Record
JICTRA is committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record. Concerns regarding published articles are evaluated to determine appropriate corrective measures in accordance with journal policy and applicable publication-ethics guidance.
Post-Publication Assessment Process
Published Article
Version of Record
↓
Error or Concern Identified
Error, integrity concern, or reliability issue
↓
Editorial Assessment
Evaluation of the nature and severity of the issue
↓
Appropriate Editorial Action
Determined according to the assessment outcome
Correction / Erratum / Corrigendum
Errors that do not invalidate the principal findings.
Expression of Concern
Substantial concerns while an investigation is ongoing.
Retraction
Unreliable findings or serious breaches of publication ethics.
The appropriate action depends on the nature, severity, and outcome of the editorial assessment.
01 Integrity of the Scholarly Record

JICTRA is committed to maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.

When an error is identified in a published article, the journal will determine the appropriate corrective action based on the nature and severity of the issue.

02 Correction / Erratum / Corrigendum

Correction / Erratum / Corrigendum may be issued when an error does not invalidate the principal findings of the article.

Purpose of a Correction
A correction addresses an identified error while preserving the scholarly record when the article's principal findings remain valid.
03 Expression of Concern

An Expression of Concern may be issued when there are substantial concerns regarding the integrity or reliability of an article and an investigation is ongoing.

Notice During Investigation
An Expression of Concern informs readers that substantial concerns are being examined while the investigation remains ongoing.
04 Retraction

Retraction may be applied when findings are unreliable due to major error, fabrication, falsification, plagiarism, duplicate publication, unethical research, manipulation of the peer-review process, or other serious breaches of publication ethics.

Grounds for Retraction
01 Major errors affecting the reliability of findings
02 Fabrication or falsification
03 Plagiarism or duplicate publication
04 Unethical research
05 Manipulation of the peer-review process
06 Other serious breaches of publication ethics
05 Publication and Accessibility of Notices

Retraction and correction notices will remain permanently accessible, clearly identify the affected article, and be linked to the original Version of Record.

Permanent Scholarly Record
Correction and retraction notices must remain accessible and clearly connected to the affected published article to maintain transparency in the scholarly record.
06 Post-Publication Discussion and Reporting Concerns

Readers may submit concerns regarding published articles to the Editorial Office. Substantive concerns will be assessed by the Editor in accordance with journal policy and applicable COPE guidance.

Reporting a Concern
Readers who identify potential errors, research-integrity issues, or other substantive concerns in published articles may contact the JICTRA Editorial Office.
The Editor will assess substantive concerns in accordance with applicable journal policies and publication-ethics guidance.
View COPE Guidance →
Core Post-Publication Principles
Research Integrity: JICTRA is committed to maintaining the reliability of the scholarly record.
Proportionate Action: Corrective measures depend on the nature and severity of identified issues.
Correction: Errors that do not invalidate principal findings may be corrected.
Expression of Concern: Substantial unresolved concerns may be communicated while an investigation is ongoing.
Retraction: Unreliable findings or serious ethical breaches may warrant retraction.
Transparency: Correction and retraction notices remain permanently accessible and linked to the original article.
Post-Publication Discussion: Substantive reader concerns are assessed by the Editor in accordance with journal policy and applicable COPE guidance.
Journal of ICT Research and Applications
Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB)