Peer Review Process

JICTRA / JOURNAL POLICIES
Peer Review Process
Journal of ICT Research and Applications
Single-Blind Peer Review
JICTRA applies a Single-Blind Peer Review process. Each manuscript is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area.
Peer Review Workflow
Manuscript Submission
↓
Similarity and Potential Plagiarism Screening
↓
Initial Editorial Screening
↓
Single-Blind Peer Review
At least two independent reviewers
↓
Reviewers' Recommendations
↓
Editorial Decision
Editorial decisions may include revision or resubmission. A final publication decision is made by the Editor.
01 Similarity and Plagiarism Screening

All manuscripts submitted to the Journal of ICT Research and Applications (JICTRA) are checked for similarity and potential plagiarism before being assigned for peer review.

02 Initial Editorial Screening

Manuscripts that pass similarity and potential plagiarism screening undergo an initial editorial screening to assess their relevance to the journal's scope, compliance with submission requirements, originality, and basic scientific quality.

03 Single-Blind Peer Review

JICTRA applies a Single-Blind Peer Review process. The identity of the reviewers is not disclosed to the authors, while reviewers may have access to the authors' identities and affiliations.

Reviewer Anonymity
Reviewer identities remain confidential to authors throughout the peer review process.
04 Reviewers and Evaluation Criteria

Each manuscript is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area. Reviewers are expected to assess the following aspects:

01 Originality and significance of the work
02 Methodological soundness
03 Validity of the results
04 Quality of analysis and discussion
05 Clarity of presentation
06 Relevance of the references
05 Reviewer Confidentiality and Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and disclose any potential conflict of interest before accepting a review assignment.

06 Editorial Decisions

Based on the reviewers' recommendations, the editor may decide to accept the manuscript, request revisions, request resubmit for review, resubmit elsewhere or decline the manuscript.

Possible Editorial Decisions
Accept Submission
The manuscript is accepted for publication.
Revisions Required
The manuscript requires revisions before further editorial consideration.
Resubmit for Review
A revised manuscript must undergo further peer review.
Resubmit Elsewhere
The manuscript is not accepted for publication in JICTRA and may be submitted elsewhere.
Decline Submission
The manuscript is declined for publication.
07 Final Publication Decision

The final decision regarding publication is made by the Editor based on the scientific quality of the manuscript, reviewers' recommendations, journal policies, and publication ethics.

08 Review Duration and Acceptance

The journal does not guarantee acceptance or a specific review duration, as the review process depends on the availability of qualified reviewers and the revisions required.

Important Information
Manuscript submission does not guarantee acceptance. The duration of peer review may vary depending on reviewer availability and the revisions required.
Journal of ICT Research and Applications
Institut Teknologi Bandung (ITB)